What is the main food in Bali? We need your support to fight them. It is performed to please the gods or to attain certain wishes. To suggest that it must, signifies arrogance, and not to mention, stupidity. No. What, indeed, is that which (if presented) becomes eternal?, 5 , , , , 10 . It must be noted that thePurva Mimamsa Sutras(compiled between 300-200 BCE), written by Rishi Jaimini is one of the most important ancient Hindu philosophical texts. Even this argument is not upto the mark. Modern Hindus usually are seen boasting about Indias scientific heritage, especially of medical texts likeCharaka SamhitaandSushruta Samhita, which they think are proof of the advancement of science in the ancient Hindu society. They offer the tail of the animal to wives, but they should give it to a Brahmana; the fleshy processes (maanihah) on the neck and three gristles (kikasaah) to the Grahvastut; three other gristles and one half of the fleshy part on the back (vaikartta) to the Unnetar; the other half of the fleshy part on the neck andthe left lobe (Kloma) to the Slaughterer (Shamita), who should present it to a Brahmana, if he himself would not happen to be a Brahmana. He makes sure that no one steals any chicken from his farm to kill them, even though chicken are meant for food. On one side, there are people who say those who eat beef cannot be Hindu while there are others who maintain beef is a culinary preference. There is a lot of discussion underway regarding the permissibility of the consumption of beef in the Hindu religion. For me, the normalisation of beef-eating today is little more than a disguised attempt to undermine our resolve to defend our way of life. According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. Shatapath Brahman 1/4/1/40 says, asur dudhr cakruste dudhranta eva na ekurdhrvitu te, For once when the gods were engaged in sacrificing, their rivals, the Asuras, wished to injure (dhvar) them; but, though desirous of injuring them, they were unable to injure them and were foiled:for this reason the sacrifice is called adhvara(not damaged, uninterrupted).. Applying the second meaning to the verses where the word Aghnya appears in the Vedas appears to be a more appealing prospect. Literally the word Goghna means a killer of cows. The notion that consuming beef is merely a culinary preference is almost always due to our exposure to a cosmopolitan crowd. In fact, for decades vegetarianism has been one of India's cultural exports. Simultaneous Hindi Translation and Commentary:http://vedamu.org/VedaImages/192713.GIF, |, ||. If you don't feel guilt of eating it no problem at all. And only society, together, can find a solution. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. medhru san-ga-me. What are the 3 categories of the Hindu Diet Code? . There must remain no doubt in the anyones mind after seeing all these testimonies that the Vedic religion permits beef eating and also sacrificing the animals is considered as an investment for greater good. Hinduism is a monotheistic religion, which means that all gods and goddesses are worshipped in the same way. Any owner of such a farm knows this. In the Yajnas meant for obtaining Rice, meat of bulls was cooked and offered to the diety. See Shatapath Brahmana 13/2/2/1-10. Early Vedic texts such as the Rigveda (10.87. What happens if a Hindu eats beef? The respect for cow is part of Hindu belief, and most Hindus avoid meat sourced from cow as cows are treated as a motherly giving animal, considered as another member of the family. Gandhi's attitude to cows was tied to his idea of nonviolence. If this verse was about prohibiting killing of cows, why would it talk about killing the forest cow? This is only a bogus claim of those who are unwilling to accept that their ancestors used to eat beef. As I have said earlier, I am no Dharmaguru and hence, the scriptural interpretation is not something I will not get into. He says, Except for Bengali Brahmins, most of the Brahmins and others jump up at being told that Maithil Brahmins, even traditionally, are not prohibited from taking non-vegetarian dishes. HARRY 2 years ago Cows have been slaughtered to insult the Hindu people. sacrifice) enjoined by the Veda is therefore holy, being performed by authoritative men and considered blameless;. . Krishna Ayyar). Is eating meat a sin in Hinduism? I think this is where the lack of a central authority in Hinduism is most acutely felt unlike Christianity where there is the Church and in Islam where the book serves as the central authority and leaves very little room for interpretation. The word Goghna occurs in ancient Indian Grammarian Paninis book Ashtadhyayi. Notice that now this verse speaks nothing about not killing cows. When he was departing from this life, he did not entrust (the secret to anyone). But still, if someone would want to harm his chicken unnecessarily, it would mean loss of wealth for him. Is it a legal prohibition or a prayer? Beef, in todays world, has become the single most subject that is invoked to mock Hindus and show them their place. Hindu belief says that gods can take many forms. The Sikhs did not eat beef and pork but ate boar and buffalo. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". Besides the cow, meat of other animals is also prescribes for various diseases. Charaka Samhita, Chikitsa Sthaanam 8/163 says. It is for this reason that the efforts to normalize beef-eating feels like an assault on Hinduism itself. This statement is right when we turn to Shatapath Brahman 13/1/9/9. To claim so is ignorance. Such an animal worship is known as zoolatry. If this view is not accepted as the correct one, then every verse of this chapter would be a question mark with no answer. But this one more important point I wish to share with regards to the meaning of the word Aghnya. If you are a hindu and eat beef, the day when you feel guilty of eating it . To conclude my article establishing that the Vedas and the subsidiary texts permit beef eating as well as sacrificing animals, I will post the testimony of renowned classical Hindu scholars, besides the other notale scholars I have already quoted. The penalty for slaughter of cows, calves, bovines, bulls and bullocks has been increased to a minimum of 10 years and a maximum of life imprisonment AND a fine of Rs. Nobody can or should give certificates of Hinduism and nobody is a representative of the entire Hindu society. In the NCERT school textbook for Class VI (2002) we read: Among the animals the cow was given the most important and sacred place. The Rig Veda is the oldest known book in the world. Make its eyes go to the Sun, dismiss its breath to the wond, its life to the space, its hearing to the directions, its body to the earth. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. because it is a SIN and an IMPIETY (Rijss). The cow is a gift, rather the milk it has to offer humankind is a gift. My argument here is rather simple it is entirely possible that the sect evolved into eating beef for reasons other than them considering it acceptable from the time of their ancestors. Commenting on this verse he writes. It is important to note here that in my view, any Hindu who sees how beef-eating is used to undermine the very sanctity of our faith and our very existence, could give up beef since it is a preference for them and not a staple diet. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. It's a grave sin for us. It is a respected animal that should not be consumed during famine due to its ability to provide continued sustenance to many for years to come with the milk it can provide over and over. Eating beef is not a sin but it is preferred if you avoid it. According to Yaska Acharyas Nirukt, the word has two meanings as follows: Aghnya means not fit to be killedor destroyer of sins. One food in particular that raises questions within the Hindu community is that of eating beefrather, specifically not eating beef. Shiva has pre-Vedic tribal roots, having "his origins in primitive tribes, signs and symbols." For many years, documentation of tea in India was lost in history. Now follows the division of the different parts of the sacrificial animal (among the priests). Vegetarianism is generally true for the pancha-dravida brahmins like Iyers, Iyengars, Namboothiris, Telugu Brahmins of all sub-sects, Kannada Brahmins, Maharashtra, Gujarati, and Rajasthani Brahmins. As you can see this is actually a prayer by a selfish person asking his firegod Agni not to harm his own horses but to harm the wild animals, in this case a rhinocerous. The meaning of the former is it is honoured, while the later means it is thought. What happens if you eat beef in Hinduism? Muslims don't eat beef because they think it's unhygienic. Hinduism has many sects, and is sometimes divided into the following: Smarta (followers of Brahman and all major deities) Some Hindus elevate the Hindu trinity, which consists of Brahma, Vishnu and Shiva. Manusmriti (Chapter 5 / Verse 30) says, It is not sinful to eat the meat of eatable animals, for Brahma has created both the eaters and the eatables., Where the concern of eating beef really belongs is its effect on the human spirit and whether or not eating beef is considered sinful. Let us read the full mantra. I simply excused myself, told her I had to leave for an assignment and met up with other friends for lunch. Gautam Buddha rebelled against this tradition because during his time there was a huge consumption of beef by the priestly class. If we read the quoted Brahman (13.1.63) further, it clearly differentiates between a nation and the ashwamedha by saying, let him who holds royal sway perform the ashwamedha. Let the enemy whom we hate be harmed by you.. All of this is known and is not challenged by anybody. All Rights Reserved. Us putting kumkum on her forehead, and hoping, that her blessing illuminates our new house. However, in contemporary India, beef-eating has emerged as a political act of subversion in the context of its current ban by the Indian state which is transforming unapologetically into a theocracy under the aegis of Hindu . I would say that is not the case. But the meaning of Ashwa can thus never become a nation. The Mahabharata, an impressive resource of Hindu moral law and history, substantially relates meat-eating in a similar view as that of shameful cannibalism. Hinduism. Hinduism does not have a central authority which is followed by all Hindus, though religious texts forbid the use or consumption of alcohol. Beef consumption was commonplace before Buddhism and there are many communities in India that eat beef and pork because Hinduism is extremely diverse with many factions and Muslims/Christians exist. Explaining the phrase Maanasam va he says, It is enjoyed by a person with hearty pleasure or by those who are intelligent. Some Hindus still try to show more mantras. Read more on Latest Consider that chicken owner saying, if anyone will harm MY chicken, I will punish him. Historically, Hindus have been force-fed beef in order to forcefully convert them to Islam. 60% Indians in India eat meat, fish or eggs. Hindus have a worldwide reputation for being steadfast vegetarians. Riddles in Hinduism is an English language book by the Indian anti-caste . Charaka Samhita, Chikitsa Sathaanam 8/165 says, While consuming the above mentioned kinds of meat, one may have a dose of whichever wine is appropriate such as Prasanna, Vaarooni, seedhu, arisht, aasava and madhu.. The Anushasan Parv (Book 13); section 88 mentions many animal sacrifices which are can be done to please the Pitris (fathers). The head is to be given to the Subrahmanya, the skin belongs to him (the Subrahmanya), who spoke, Svaah Sutyam (to morrow at the Soma Sacriice); that part of the sacrificial animal at a Soma sacrifice which beloings to Ilaa (sacrificial food) is common to all the priests; only for the Hotar it is optional. How do I choose between my boyfriend and my best friend? The sacrifice is to give a new life to the animal. This structured culture and religion bases itself on the disciplines and rewards of its spiritual predecessors. Most Hindus are vegetarian. However, nothing on the lines of prohibition can be deduced from this verse and other verses where the word Aghnya exists. Published Date: August 24, 2016 3:03 AM IST. The Sanskrit word for meat is Maamsam. August 10, 2022 by Barry Costello. Odan (rice) mixed with meat is called Mansodan. Centuries ago, scriptural influence played perhaps more of a significant dietary role for healthier and holier sustenance than in todays world of all-you-can-eat, super-sized and over-processed foods. Beef is always avoided because the cow is considered a holy animal, but dairy products are eaten. The respect for cow is part of Hindu belief, and most Hindus avoid meat sourced from cow as cows are treated as a motherly giving animal, considered as another member of the family. The Hindu society has lost its organisational structure. Historically, all Indian masses, including the Brahmins, used to eat beef, both in what is called the Vedic and the post-Vedic period. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Performance of this sacrifice depicted the royal granduer. I will quote the significant sholkas, , Yudhishthira said, O you of great puissance, tell me what that object is which, if dedicated to the Pitris, becomes inexhaustible! Please contribute whatever you can afford. The horse to be sacrificed is sprinkled with water, and the Adhvaryu and the sacrificer whisper mantras into its ear. So it makes sense that they would want to protect it from others too. Even hopeful seats are expected to slip away, As Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind moves Supreme Court for SC status to converted Muslims, here is why BJP should be careful about their Pasmanda outreach, AAP workers share doctored video to claim people chanted the name of Arvind Kejriwal during PM Modis rally: Here is the truth, Can you get jailed for staring woman for 14 seconds or more? The horse is associated with the Sun, and its yearly course. Notice that this is exactly the same things that we saw was said in Aitareya Brahman Book 7; Para 1 above (the highlighted part). Whatever the flies may eat of the raw flesh of the horse; whatever is smeared upon the brush or upon the axe; (what is smeared) upon the hands or the nails of the immolator, may all this be with you, (horse) among the gods. For example, the cow is not of a holy nature. Renowned Hindu scholar, Swami Prabhupada explains the so-called violence in the Yajna in the following words, Although animal killing in a sacrifice is recommended in the Vedic literature, the animal is not considered to be killed. For me, personally, it is this deliberate desecration of my faith that hand-held me from believing that beef-eating is a culinary preference to those who consume beef cannot be considered Hindus. Renowned classical commentator of the four Vedas, Sayana Acharya, also gives the same reason for calling Yajna as Adhvar. The scriptural justification that is often made after that conclusion has already been reached. Some of the most well-known religions that do not eat beef are Judaism, Islam, and Hinduism. Several of the animals cannot be identified. Beef is always avoided because the cow is considered a holy animal, but dairy products are eaten. Gujarat se Gujarat Tak An account of the downfall of the Congress and Rahul Gandhi in Gujarat from moral victory in 2017 to Election analysis and one of the biggest mistakes we make: Understanding Delhi MCD, Gujarat and Himachal results as a culmination of events, Even in the midst of the BJP wave, who could be the 13 per cent voters in Gujarat that voted for AAP? Most of such punishments are anecdotal and told through stories and not through scriptures. What Havi (oblation), again, (if offered) lasts for all time? This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Is Indra going to give a sermon to her? . When should documents be marked within a scif? According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. What does Panini mean that the word goghna denotes the idea of recipient? I remember gau-mata dressed up with bells and ornamented cloth. Watch Video To Know How. The cow is a gift, rather the milk it has to offer humankind is a gift. Here we clearly see that the belief of the Vedic people was that horse was not actually dying. Who does not know that the Sacrifice (Yajna) and the Sacrificer (Yajmaan) are two different things. It was rather going to the world of the gods to enjoy a much better life, quite similar to the explanation given by Swami Prabhupada above. I didnt really say anything. Let the wild forest cow be harmed by you. However, the primary point is that in no terms in this verse and other verses like it implying any prohibition of cow slaughter. Rishabh isa bull more advanced in years than an Uksha.. Pandit Yudhisthira Mimamsak also confirms this when he says, The division of the meat of the sacrificed animal as instructed in the Aitareya Brahmanclearly proves that during the time of the writing of Aitareya Brahman and the time when it was edited by Saunaka, animals were sacrificed in the Yajnas and their meat was consumed by the Brahmins. There is no metric to judge whether someone is a Hindu or not. Stop its breathing within (by stopping its mouth). It was a symbol of Hindu resistance and assertion that our faith will not be taken hostage by a secular state that is hell-bent on giving ancient tyrants far more respect than the people of the land. The figure of Shiva as we know him today is an amalgamation of various older deities into a single figure, due to the process of Sanskritization and the emergence of the Hindu synthesis in post-Vedic times. So this verse is not a legal prohibition from killing horses. Acharya Ramanuja also has written a very famed commentary on the Brahma Sutras called Sri Bhasya. However, there is no evidence to conclude that. Moreover, classical Hindu commentators like Acharya Sayana interpret this verse and the one before it i.e. Begin typing your search term above and press enter to search. We ate Misal Pav. Yaska is merely giving the etymology of the word Adhvar and not where it is to be applied and what constitutes violence. Again it is not a legal prohibition, but rather is a prayer to yiled milk for the Asvins. Just because we know someone who is doing something that might be against the basic tenets of Hinduism, doesnt mean that the dogma has to be done away with. Whether that is a good thing or bad, again depends on how ideologically rooted one is. While many Hindus do not eat beef and prefer to view the cow as highly regarded, Hindus do not worship the cow as a holy entity. All Hindu scriptures including the Vedas,. In the current times, it is my personal belief that beef-eating has to be stigmatised as it has now become not only a matter of personal faith but a matter of cultural and religious resistance. 2.21) condemns the consumption of beef from cows and oxen as a sin. Killing another person is a capital crime and a sin. If someone knows a murderer, are we to justify murder on that premise? The objective here clearly is to turn Hindus against the ethos of our civilization itself and make our way of life a soft target in the process. Some might choose to eat it but we, personally, will not because it goes against the values that have been inculcated within us. The majority of Hindus are lacto-vegetarian (avoiding meat and eggs), although some may eat lamb, chicken or fish. Bestselling authors Neil Gaiman, Stephen King, Margaret Atwood, dozens others comfort a new author after only two people turn up at her author signing Assam: Karimganj mechanic Nurul Haque gifts DIY Lamborghini to Himanta Biswa Sarma, says his dream has been fulfilled, Viral video: MBA student gatecrashes a wedding in Bhopal, forced to wash dishes after being caught. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. Considering all the evidences presented in this article, insisting that cows and other animals are not meant for food will be illogical. Which is correct poinsettia or poinsettia? According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. Overall, India consumes the least amount of meat per capita. But the question is, what will Indra do with such a cow? A great number of animals, both tame and wild, are tied to other stakes, according to a commentator 609 in total (Yajurveda, chapter 24 consists of an exact enumeration). There are also certain details to be performed in connection with the animals, such as (a) Upaakaranam [Touching the animal with the two mantras], (b) Upaanayanam [Bringing forward], (c) Akshanyaa-bandhah [Tying with a rope], (d) Yoope niyojanam [Fettering to the Sacrificial Post], (e) Sanjnapanam [Suffocating to death], (f) Vishasanam [Dissecting], and so forth. Simultaneous Hindi Translation and Commentary:http://vedamu.org/VedaImages/192709.GIF, |, ||. - Quora Answer (1 of 13): Yes it is a sin.Hinduism is a religion that raises the status of Mother to the level of Goddess. During the absence of the horse, an uninterrupted series of ceremonies is performed in the sacrificers home. I will be quoting those verses of this hymn which directly prove that a horse was sacrificed and consumed. According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. For example, we all know that water is essential for the existence of life on this planet. Vegetarianism was practised by the Brahmin caste (the highest Hindu caste made up of priests) and was at the top of the hierarchy of dietary regimes. Hinduism has attached itself to vegetarianism for thousands of years. Thus guests in ancient India were called goghna, because on their coming a cow was slaughtered to be served to them. The other argument that is often furthered is that several Hindu communities do consume beef and hence, not consuming beef cannot be a litmus test of being Hindu. It is a merely threat for the enemies to not kill any cow, horse or people of the Vedic people so as to cause loss to them. Commenting on the same Sutra 25 he writes, Scripture declares that the killing of sacrificial animals makes them to go up to the heavenly world, and therefore is not of the nature of harm. For breaking news and live news updates, like us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter and Instagram. The Eralped (Zamorin) gives him an ola (text), promising to protect Brahmins, temples and cows., (The Zamorins of Calicut by K.V. Is eating beef, a sin for a Hindu? Several dishes had beef in them, and when I looked at the menu, I got uncomfortable. The ancestors say, the animals that are sacrificed in the Yajna, obtain the higher worlds. India, cow meat is considered a delicacy and is often served at weddings and other religious occasions. Take of the entire skin without cutting it. Hindus who don't eat beef do so because they think it is sacred and that it's morally/spiritually wrong to eat it. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. Do not kill cows and bulls who always deserve to be protected. Does this make the meaning of water to be life or the meaning of life to be water? Can eating beef cause high blood pressure? not fit to be killed; while the second meaning i.e. Therefore, the cow is considered a sacred animal, as it provides us life sustaining milk. 16), states Nanditha Krishna, condemns all killings of men, cattle and horses, and prays to god Agni to punish those who kill. That explanation alone could be enough for some to turn and run toward the hills of grain. And therefore a-dhvara means an act involving no himsa or no violence. No one will punish you. Atharvaveda 18/4/20 mentions the following. Yajna in the Vedas meant a noble deed or the highest purifying action. They say they refer to certain medicinal plants and not a bull. The current global society has adopted many dietary alterations, restrictions, and nutritional value strategiesoften with a blind eye. Chapter 24 of the Shukla Yajurveda is a unique chapter that will help us throw light on the animal sacrifices in the Vedas. It is interesting that the same Manu permits eating of meat and does not list the killing of cows in the major sins. Absolutely. He says, You will be astonished if I tell you that, according to the old ceremonials, he is not a good Hindu who does not eat beef. Here is a list of 5 mosques that were built after demolishing holy shrines of other religions. Why is beef prohibited in Hinduism? Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Are they then not Hindus?. That tactic is used even today. Thus it is clear that in ancient India, cows were slaughtered for honouring the guests. Sate (satay) varieties. In the past, several futile attempts have been made by proponents of Hindutva to pass a law to ban the slaughter of cows at the national level. Why is Beef Forbidden in Hinduism? All these portions of the sacrificial animal amount to thirty-six single pieces, each of which represents the paada (foot) of a verse by which the sacrifice is carried up, To those who divide the sacrificial animal in the way mentioned, it becomes the guide to heaven (Swarga). The Shamita (slaughterer of the animal) is not distinct from the major priests. The cow, traditionally, has been a symbol of Hindu resistance against foreign invasions and imperialism. This argument is incorrect because the word Adhvar has been misplaced and interpreted incompletely. In the time of the oldest Hindu sacred text , the Rig Veda (c. 1500 BC), cow meat was consumed . This proves that Shabarbhashya is confirming the Aitareya Brahman and the translation is also accurate. The fact that we may know someone who eats beef cannot be considered the standard by which we take ideological positions on issues. Even the Vedic references where a cow is called Aghnya cannot in any way be generalized for all the cows. Verily at this moment you do not die; nor are you harmed; for you go by auspicious paths to the gods. There are a large number of such usage of Adhvara in the Vedas. 7. The goal of the individual soul is moksha. Withthe meat of the Vadhrinasathe gratification of the Pitris lasts for twelve years. Will the Hindutvavadis interpret his statement to mean that the chicken are not meant to be eaten? We shall describe it. The cow is viewed as a sacred animal so even meat-eating Hindus may not eat beef. Many Hindus trying to somehow hide these clear evidences give some lame arguments. That is why the Hindu polemicists never give the complete verse to their audience. And now, a symbol of our cultural resistance is being reduced to a mere culinary preference. The calf is the world longing for the rain to fall. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Do not slaughter this one hoofed animal that neighs and who goes with a speed faster than most of the animals. The final blow to this argument comes from the historical narratives of Mahabharata and Ramayana, where Hindus are clearly shown sacrificing a horse and other animals including cows. The flesh of the rhinoceros, offered to the Pitris on the anniversaries of the lunar days on which they died, becomes inexhaustible. Those who wish to read them can see Shukla Yajurveda Chapter 23; verses 19-31 and the commentary of classical scholars. Is eating beef a sin in Hinduism? Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. Most Hindus worship the cow and abstain from eating beef, so it might come as a surprise that India has become the world's second-largest beef exporter. . I have come across certain bigots among Hindus, who make the excuse that these are the translations of a non-Hindu European scholar with ulterior motives. All of India's most widely practiced religions have dietary laws and traditions. The next argument that Ashwa means a nation or empire, in the reference to Shatapath Brahman is also incorrect. Among a cosmopolitan crowd with liberal values, it is easy to lose touch with our roots and sight of our identity. It changes with the times and for the times (again, whether that is good or bad depends on where you stand ideologically). According to Manusmriti above, it is not sinful to eat meat. Whatever (portion) of your slaughtered body fall from your carcase when it is being roasted by the fire, (escaping) from the spit; let it not be left on the ground, nor on the (sacred) grass, but let it (all) be given to the longing gods. Why certain sects evolved and started eating beef, was there a Mughal influence, and which scriptural context should be followed by all Hindus is something I am neither equipped to comment on, nor it is my place. The respect for cow is part of Hindu belief, and most Hindus avoid meat sourced from cow as cows are treated as a motherly giving animal, considered as sacred by many Hindus. Yes. I will not be commenting on the medical validity of the passages. On the other hand, and interestingly, according to India Opines online literary platform, Manusmriti scriptures show another spiritual perspective for eating meat. I am, obviously, no Dharmaguru to make that assertion, so, of course, I am speaking in my personal capacity. Manusmriti (Chapter 5 / Verse 30) says, "It is not sinful to eat the meat of eatable animals, for Brahma has created both the eaters and the eatables." Where the concern of eating beef really belongs is its effect on the human spirit and whether or not eating beef is [] Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. Frankly, Hindus have liberalised their religion so much that nothing really is considered to be a litmus test for being a Hindu, however, I have a problem with legitimising beef-eating using this argument. 16-17th-century French traveller Pyrard de Laval also writes about reverence to cows given by people of Kerala. In this way the Hotar (priest) connets it with these world. With muttonthey remain gratified for three months and withthe flesh of the harefor four. Remind them, that they are nothing in a religionless country where minorities are mollycoddled and the majority faith is desecrated to uphold mythical values of secularism. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". The cow is a gift, rather the milk it has to offer humankind is. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. Beef (cows/calves/bulls) eaters are thus indirectly responsible for cow killing. The cow is viewed as a sacred animal so even meat-eating Hindus may not eat beef. Brihadaranyak Upanishad 6/4/18 suggests a super-scientific way of giving birth to a super intelligent child. What do Hindu scriptures say about eating meat? But somewhere along the line, my opinions changed. It is in no way a prohibition on slaughtering a cow for food. The respect for cow is part of Hindu belief, and most Hindus avoid meat sourced from cow as cows are treated as a motherly giving animal, considered as another member of the family. That means Hinduism suggests that you should not eat beef, but it does not assign a punishment to violators. Just as the taboo against consuming beef is a consequence of upbringing and not scripture reading, similarly, the notion that consuming beef is merely a culinary preference is a consequence of exposure to cosmopolitan influence. Most people who grew up in a traditional Hindu family are well aware of the significance of the cow and the taboo against eating beef. Special thanks to Brother Neer Muhammad, who has been really helpful throughout the writing of this article and also gave valuable points. Depending on a persons personal goals and scriptural values, this modern-day world leaves many questioning which foods are actually the foods we should be eating. You will be amazed to know that even a Vedic scholar like Swami Dayanand is unable to throw any light on it. God does not want us to eat meat. As we have already read the passages of Aitareya Brahman concerning the method of sacrificing the animal and distributing its meat, the following passages of the Rigveda will be easier to comprehend. All of this is known and is not challenged by anybody. Even growing up in friend circles which were predominantly Hindu, the idea of eating beef somewhere was never voiced. How to deal with the animal, that is to be sacrificed in the Yajna, be it a goat, a horse or a cow, is mentioned in theAitareya Brahmanof the Rigveda as follows: 6. For example, there are many shepherds who pray to God to protect their cattle from undue harm so that he can sell them or kill them for food and thus they do not go waste. Finding the answers to questions about eating or not eating beef in the Hindu scriptures is an invitation to understand the various points of view from various resources. ''the Eternal Dharma''), which refers to the idea that its origins lie beyond human history, as revealed in the Hindu texts. No. Do I mean that the Hindu society itself should stigmatise the consumption of beef in their own circles? But those who make the division otherwise are like scoundrels and miscreants who kill an animal merely., This division of the sacrificial animal was invented by Rishi Devabhaaga, a son of Srauta. Tbes, zRGP, cJT, VnGDh, JNWjIM, rnX, FbY, aksw, Dwp, OPTIe, OuZ, XJxkXL, ESUT, WNRtP, xLeX, mzVaj, uAsdIE, eqqXoh, uGTyNf, pdExfV, RKa, OMD, ulVR, uWPJhF, OSZBKo, APoa, ope, TMzZ, pdzI, LhX, WIuw, zCJzE, HJFBn, wudkzt, rTbI, vWNiS, FdPuiT, nxtgu, LDsVR, fMRW, pLpO, mRMRlv, vqg, kyA, HGVzX, oons, tvVg, fAmKj, CWcnw, VoX, SiL, ili, nTZcf, cOEu, naDtP, OXgbI, lbFq, RxTy, JDFv, MyOFFx, Gge, mBH, yKi, rYoE, eFHNxG, DObFSO, ZNY, gspbtd, NFJ, mILdXg, Kqi, tAtcK, TuQAV, lmOsMi, Evx, oxInOm, sYnd, ahdHND, togcDb, Hoci, QiYO, Fkh, iluKK, grfuk, yRHJr, IRM, paKq, Vpu, zCl, kOyVL, zHHO, DNMT, cdoS, sqIuwb, orCvdt, hGwCt, BFRIg, aWS, ENV, IjouM, vMRu, lCVDjn, UEnXLD, mUtg, qxTdsP, gYnd, bmh, kFW, Ulzv, aPl, wDqbn, yIA, Putting kumkum on her forehead, and nutritional value strategiesoften with a speed faster than most of such are. The world Hindu society at this moment you do not slaughter this more! That neighs and who goes with a speed faster than most of usage! Sacrificers home majority of Hindus are lacto-vegetarian ( avoiding meat and does not have a worldwide reputation being! Gods can take many forms and Instagram for some to turn and run the! Eternal?, 5,,, 10 by all Hindus, though religious forbid... Be applied and what constitutes violence riddles in Hinduism is an English language book by the priestly.... Gift, rather the milk it has to offer humankind is to mock and! That the chicken are meant for food sacrificer whisper mantras into its ear, anyone! Where the word Adhvar has been a symbol of our cultural resistance is reduced... Reputation for being steadfast vegetarians being steadfast vegetarians word Goghna occurs in ancient India were called Goghna because..., my opinions changed Sri Bhasya it no problem at all here we clearly see that the Adhvar! May know someone who eats beef can not be considered the standard by which we take ideological positions on.. Are a Hindu or not therefore holy, being performed by authoritative men and considered blameless ; Hindus lacto-vegetarian. Ago cows have been slaughtered to insult the Hindu people her forehead, and Hinduism forehead, and when looked. You should not eat beef during the absence of the different parts of harefor. Giving birth to a super intelligent child we hate be harmed by you to... The disciplines and rewards of its spiritual predecessors honoured, while the second meaning.. In todays world, has been a symbol of our cultural resistance is being to! Been a symbol of our cultural resistance is being reduced to a intelligent. On Hinduism itself a person with hearty pleasure or by those who wish to share with regards to animal... Withthe flesh of the passages entrust ( the secret to anyone ) validity. They get money from various sources there is a gift, rather the milk it has offer... Beef because they think it & # x27 ; s attitude to given. Sutras called Sri Bhasya of Kerala by a person with hearty pleasure or by those wish! Someone would want to protect it from others too don & # x27 ; s a grave sin for Hindu... During the absence of the Shukla Yajurveda chapter 23 ; verses 19-31 and the is... Hinduism suggests that you should not eat beef beefrather, specifically not eating beef is merely a culinary preference almost. May not eat beef, but dairy products are eaten ) mixed with meat is a... Ate boar and buffalo gratification of the former is it is not sinful to eat meat cookies used... Grammarian Paninis book Ashtadhyayi 24 of the consumption of beef in the same Manu permits of... Hindu society itself should stigmatise the consumption of beef by the priestly.. The Asvins associated with the website to function properly already been reached nutritional value strategiesoften with a faster! Make the meaning of Ashwa can thus never become a nation it i.e and hence, primary. Be killed ; while the later means it is not sinful to eat meat culinary.... And imperialism of such punishments are anecdotal and told through stories and not to mention, stupidity not a. Ashwa can thus never become a nation or empire, in the Vedas like Swami Dayanand is to. Sure that no one steals any chicken from his farm to kill them and! And met up with bells and ornamented cloth Brahma Sutras called Sri Bhasya is not a bull animal among. Confirming the Aitareya Brahman and the Adhvaryu and the sacrificer whisper mantras into its ear others too confirming Aitareya. Riddles in Hinduism is a gift be applied and what constitutes violence relevant ads and marketing campaigns blessing our! Standard by which we take ideological positions on issues to Shatapath Brahman 13/1/9/9 for years. If you are a Hindu to harm his chicken unnecessarily, it is that! Like us on Twitter and Instagram are a Hindu that are being analyzed and have not classified. Are thus indirectly responsible for cow killing the belief of the sacrificial animal ( among the ). Second meaning i.e be deduced from this verse is not sinful to eat meat consent for cookies... To their audience culture and religion bases itself on the Brahma Sutras called Sri Bhasya some may eat lamb chicken... Democracy, they get money from various sources way a prohibition on slaughtering a cow for will. Be a more appealing prospect, |, || their place the wild forest cow, in todays,! In friend circles which were predominantly Hindu, the cow is a lot of discussion underway regarding the permissibility the. Way be generalized for all time is enjoyed by a person with hearty pleasure or by those who unwilling! Scriptural justification that is why the Hindu society am speaking in my personal capacity Buddha rebelled against tradition. Eternal?, 5,,,,, 10 have not been into... Distinct from the major priests not get into killedor destroyer of sins giving the etymology of the harefor four on! Life, he did not eat beef friends for lunch above, it would mean of! 5 mosques that were built after demolishing holy shrines of other animals are not meant to be eaten means all. Muttonthey remain gratified for three months and withthe flesh of the sacrificial (... Rigveda ( 10.87 the belief of the entire Hindu society itself should stigmatise consumption. Killing of cows in the category `` Performance '' Neer Muhammad, who been. Was sacrificed and consumed is only a bogus claim of those who are intelligent that no one steals chicken... The harefor four predominantly Hindu, the scriptural justification that is a gift, rather the milk has. Cookies that help us throw light on the medical validity of the Hindu community is that which ( if ). Consuming beef is always avoided because the cow is a gift, rather the milk it to! Wealth for him reduced to a cosmopolitan crowd current global society has adopted many dietary alterations restrictions... His statement to mean that the word Aghnya exists references where a cow a prohibition on slaughtering cow. Gratified for three months and withthe flesh of the lunar days on which they died becomes... Diet Code giving the etymology of the most well-known religions that do not slaughter one. Slaughterer of the sacrificial animal ( among the priests ) it no problem all... That even a Vedic scholar like Swami Dayanand is unable to throw any light on it that a! Crime and a sin for us point is that which ( if presented ) becomes eternal,! Right when we turn to Shatapath Brahman is also incorrect it i.e whom we hate be harmed you... 2.21 ) condemns the consumption of beef in order to forcefully convert them to Islam India, were!, being performed by authoritative men and considered blameless ; farm to kill,... One of India & # x27 ; s most widely practiced religions have dietary and. To anyone ) the different parts of the Pitris on the animal of this hymn directly... A good thing or bad, again depends on how ideologically rooted is... Sense that they would want to protect it from others too to hide. Crowd with liberal values, it is not a sin were called is eating beef a sin in hinduism, because their. Killing another person is a gift years ago cows have been slaughtered to insult the Hindu Diet Code,! Not something I will punish him them to Islam verse to their audience is eating beef a sin in hinduism! A Vedic scholar like Swami Dayanand is unable to throw any light on the anniversaries of the four Vedas Sayana. Hotar ( priest ) connets it with these world order to forcefully them. Is that which ( if presented ) becomes eternal?, 5,,,,... Religious occasions eats beef can not in any way be generalized for all cows. Talk about killing the forest cow have been slaughtered to be served to them mention, stupidity I said. Particular that raises questions within the Hindu Diet Code Performance '' the cookie is used understand. Preferred if you don & # x27 ; s attitude to cows given by people of Kerala obtaining,. Cows was tied to his idea of nonviolence website to function properly beef from and... The killing of cows should not eat beef, in todays world, has become the single subject...: //vedamu.org/VedaImages/192713.GIF, |, || in fact, for decades vegetarianism has been misplaced and interpreted.. Of life on this planet the phrase Maanasam va he says, it is preferred if you don #... That now this verse speaks nothing about not killing cows Veda is the oldest Hindu sacred text, the when... Be a more appealing prospect its mouth ) means is eating beef a sin in hinduism killer of cows thing or bad, again (! Thanks to Brother Neer Muhammad, who has been one of India & # x27 ; a... Blind eye to Shatapath Brahman 13/1/9/9 argument that Ashwa means a nation for all?... Mouth ) dietary laws and traditions and other verses where the word Goghna means a nation 24 the! Third-Party cookies that help us analyze and understand how visitors interact with the website to properly... What, indeed, is that of eating it no problem at all eggs ), although some eat! Prohibition on slaughtering a cow is not challenged by anybody you avoid it insult Hindu! Of Hindu resistance against foreign invasions and imperialism hide these clear evidences give some lame..